Powered by Invision Power Board

12801024800Auto

Reviews for Chapter 5 of That Thing That Happened That Time That's Really No Big Deal by Forgotten Conscience Reviews for Chapter:


Jinxgirl(Signed)
28th Apr 08
Ch: 5
Well what Buffy did and said was fair anyway, at least she's taking the blame like she should. Satsu I really, really don't like. What a whiner. Just deal with it. And Buffy pretty please change your mind about Faith smile.gif
Author Feedback: Aww come on, young love is some of the hardest kind to deal with and Satsu is having a seriously hard time with it all of the sudden. She had to react in an honest way. As for changing Buffy's mind about Faith, well... you'll find out things in the next chapter so I'll just leave it there. smile.gif Thanks.

27th Mar 08
Ch: 5
Holy crap. What a chapter. What a conversation! It sucks that Buffy seems to be turning them both down...but good for her. At least she finally pulled in enough courage to talk to them about about it and be honest about everything that has transpired.
Author Feedback: Heh, I'm glad you thought it was a good way to do it. I thought so too, but a few people objected to the idea. It was courageous of her though. smile.gif She's gotta be completely honest or it'll only lead to bad things happening. Of course, that's no guarantee, as you already know from the final chapter. biggrin.gif Thanks a bunch.

anon(Anonymous)
21st Mar 08
Ch: 5
Alright so I just read through this whole thing, and while I did enjoy the premise and plot, you really need to rewrite this. Just about any fiction needs to be written in past tense, yours is written primarily in the present emphatic tense; third person plural. If you're not sure what that means, send me an email, or just google it.
Author Feedback: Hmm, now this the kind of feedback I never thought I'd get. An actual critique of my overall writing style. I like it. smile.gif I write it in the present emphatic tense (yes I actually know what that means, heh) because I see the story in that context. Writing it involves seeing it in my head as it happens, which happens in the present tense, so it comes out that way when I write it down. I'm not opposed to evolving as a writer though, so I may just take you up on that offer. Thank you for saying you enjoyed the premise and plot, those are key for me above everything else most of the time. smile.gif

Kirk(Anonymous)
21st Mar 08
Ch: 5
thumbup.gif

Nice ending.

I think it was really well done, and pretty well along the lines I imagine it will go, with or without Faith being in the picture.
Author Feedback: Well that's not the end. smile.gif But I'm glad you liked it anyway. I was expecting mostly negative responses because of how it wasn't a happy shippy ending to the chapter the way some were expecting. But at least someone out there appreciates where I went with it, and I hope you'll appreciate the final chapter just as much. It probably won't be entirely what you were expecting either. smile.gif Thanks a lot for your opinion, it means a lot.

Just Me(Anonymous)
21st Mar 08
Ch: 5
What a gutless decision by Buffy. She gave neither relationship a chance and killed both before they have a chance to go anywhere. At least Buffy's trying to be an honest coward.

Faith and Sastu can do better than Buffy. After the way Buffy treated them I really hope Buffy ends up with neither.
Author Feedback: Wow, smile.gif now if that isn't the most direct anti-Buffy sentiment I've ever read I don't know what is. thumbup.gif Thanks, I actually appreciate your opinion. But I'm curious, was I the only one of the two of us who actually understood Buffy's conversation with Angel in Chosen? Getting into a relationship of any kind in Buffy's frame of mind is exactly the wrong thing for her to do.

She's always defined herself by the person she's with, and that doesn't make sense. If she were to get into a relationship with Faith or Satsu, she'd be doing the same thing she'd done before with her previous relationships. All of which ended badly I might point out. It takes incredible courage and guts to be able to resist that which she might want most and stand on her own two feet. That's what she did.

Where's the cowardess in being honest with people you care about even though it might hurt them? Honesty sucks and it doesn't always make for a happy ending, but there's a reason why they say it's always the best policy. Because it is.

Anyway, despite my little rant there that went on longer than it probably should have, I appreciate your feedback and your comments about the story. I'd rather have an honest opinion then positive reinforcement for the sake of sparing my feelings. Thank you again and I hope you keep reading my stuff. smile.gif

NGBlue(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
Oi I'm holding onto this cliff, hanging on for my dear life.

How could you? That is so....ugh meanie! So Buffy picks neither? I hope Faith tries to show her the error of her ways wink.gif
Author Feedback: You know, that's the first piece of feedback I've gotten that actually seems to get what the whole point of the scene is. Thanks a bunch, it's appreciated. smile.gif As for Buffy's decision, she made the one that made the most sense for herself and everyone involved, no matter how much it might suck. YOu'll have to wait and see if "Faith shows her the error of her ways" or not. smile.gif Thanks again for the feedback.

mika(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
ooh... buffy's still a bitch...
i like.. heeheee
nice update
Author Feedback: Uh... okay... not clear on why Buffy's still a bitch. I mean, okay yeah, she had that one line with the knife word in it, but Faith was sort've a bitch by saying what she said about Satsu. Or at least that how I look at it, I'm just the author though. What do I know? biggrin.gif Glad you like the update though, it's appreciated that you left some feedback.

slayertash(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
Well that was completely unfair of Buffy! And how stupid is she to not explore with Faith...how does she know it is only physical!
Author Feedback: Lol, actually I think it was the absolutely most fair thing Buffy could have done. smile.gif But I'm always open to opposing opinions. Buffy's had some experience with relationships in the past, maybe all she's feeling for Faith right now is the physical attraction. If that's true, which I sorta know to be true, smile.gif it's probably reasonable for her to assume that's as far as it goes, given her lack of experience with the females of the species. biggrin.gif It could be otherwise, it could be just that. she's not willing to take that chance in finding out, especially with Satsu around. Thanks for leaving feedback though, I appreciate it.

WitherAway(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
mellow.gif I doubt I've counted right, but ... this is the .... second time that Buffy shot Faith down in this fic, eh?

At the moment I'm really hoping Buffy doesn't get a happy ending... Ah well.

The story is great thus far and I can't wait (I probably can...) to see how it really ends. thumbup.gif
Author Feedback: The number two sounds about right. Though I'm curious, is it because Buffy shot Faith down that you hope Buffy doesn't get a happy ending? Because that seems like a terrible thing to wish on a person who only wanted to be honest with her and do what makes sense for her own sake. But I guess I sorta understand where that comes from. And what if Buffy's unhappy ending comes at the expense of Faith? How would you feel about the ending then? smile.gif Cause you never know, that might happen (it won't, but it might). smile.gif I'm glad you thought the story has been good so far, I've tried to make it as interesting and worthwhile to read as possible and you seem to be telling me that it is. Thanks. smile.gif

youn2731(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
Interesting spin on this. I'm wondering if the final chapter will end up with Buffy being by herself? Also, I think you were kinda harsh with the Satsu explosion. While I do believe, she would tear up at Buffy's words, she doesn't seem like the type to say something like that. She seems too controlled. I do like this story though, despite the fact that it's kind of depressing.
Author Feedback: I've always been of the mind that control and understanding go out the window when emotions get involved. Satsu's feelings for Buffy are very real and she just got shot down by someone who wants to be "just friends". It always seems like the right thing to do from the perspective of the one saying it, but it cuts deep. Which is sort've an ironic statement if you're me and you know what I know. biggrin.gif

My fics in general tend to have a rather depressing overtone to them, but I always try and look for the good in the bad, the light in the dark, the happiness in the pain. The thing that makes the badness a little less bad. Hopefully this fic will be no different at the end of it all, which is what's coming next so we'll know for sure soon. smile.gif Thanks for saying you liked it.

rebalabroo(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
Aww come on Buffy grow some balls and give faith a go... i would tongue.gif Awesome update... cant wait to see how it ends... PMS..
Author Feedback: That would've been terribly inapproriate and outright mean to do in front of Satsu wouldn't it? And that's assuming that's even what she really wants. I was kinda attempting to give the opposite impression. Did I fail somewhere? smile.gif Thanks for enjoying it though, I don't think I have the right internal organs to have PMS, but I'll do my best to post more soon. smile.gif

RoutineRiot(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
Well, I liked where it was going until the very end there. I think Buffy's last comment was unnecessarilary harsh. I can't wait for the last chapter.
Author Feedback: Everything about the ending seems okay to me. smile.gif But then I might be slightly biased since I did sorta write it. Maybe I'll go back over it and think about what you said regarding the ending. Of course, that would take me away from my eventual writing of the ending. And I'm a little more inclined towards moving on to the conclusion, because it's gonna be fun. smile.gif Thanks for enjoying it though, it's appreciated.

kenyon87(Signed)
20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
buffy needs to make up her damn mind she either wants faith including the whole connection or not, hopefully she does and realises before its too late, anyways great add update real soon, rock on! peace:)
Author Feedback: Seems like she already made up her mind to me. Why? Does it not seem that way to you? smile.gif She's letting them both down easy because in the long run it'll be better for everyone. Won't it? I mean, unless there was some sort of last minute plot twist that coming that I don't know about. smile.gif Could that be it? smile.gif Maybe we should both find out when I finally get around to finishing the last chapter.

20th Mar 08
Ch: 5
huh.gif So, nothing more than physical? Heh, who the hell does Buffy think she is kidding. Everyone knows it's more than physical! She better figure that out in the next chapter wink.gif or she'll be losing someone very right for her.

P.S. I love Xander! Hehe...
Author Feedback: smile.gif Well, at least Buffy's being fair and honest with everyone right? That's an improvement isn't it? No more going around in circles trying to act like things aren't happening because they are. There's credit to Buffy for that isn't there? As for anything else that might happen later... all things in time. smile.gif

Oh, and I'm glad you liked Xander, he's one of those characters that's hard to do because his humour is sometimes very nuanced without being in your face like Faith can be. I appreciate the comments on him, it helps.